← Guides · CELPIP Speaking

CELPIP Speaking Task 5: comparing two options without rambling

By Suman Joshi · October 2026 · 9 min read

The short answer

In CELPIP Speaking Task 5, you get 60 seconds to choose one of two options without speaking. Then a friend or family member suggests something different, and you get 60 seconds to prepare and 60 seconds to talk them into your original choice.

Strong answers do three things. They compare your choice with their option on two points that matter to that person. They stay friendly while still pushing. And they end with a clear request before the minute runs out. Weak answers read the details off the screen, list five half-finished reasons, or get cut off mid-sentence.

How CELPIP Speaking Task 5 works

Task 5 is called Comparing and Persuading. It is the fifth of eight scored tasks in the CELPIP Speaking test, which takes about 15 minutes and is recorded on a computer. There is no examiner in the room.

StageTimeWhat you do
Part 1: choose60 secondsRead a short situation and the details of two options. Pick one. You don't speak.
Part 2: prepare60 secondsYour choice now sits next to a new option that the other person prefers. Plan your case.
Part 2: speak60 secondsPersuade that person to go with your choice. Recording starts and stops on its own.

Two rules follow from this. First, you defend the option you picked in Part 1, so don't switch sides when the new option looks better. Second, the comparison in Part 2 is between your choice and their option. The option you rejected in Part 1 has left the conversation.

What the rater is listening for

CELPIP scores every Speaking response on the same four dimensions, and your Speaking level comes from all eight tasks together. Here is what each dimension means in Task 5 specifically.

CELPIP dimensionWhat it means in Task 5
Content/CoherenceYour reasons are clear, developed with a detail or example, and in a sensible order.
VocabularyYou use precise comparison words (closer, cheaper, more flexible, less tiring) instead of repeating "good" and "nice".
ListenabilitySteady rhythm, clear pronunciation, few restarts, and grammar that doesn't get in the listener's way.
Task FulfillmentYou talk to the named person, defend your Part 1 choice against theirs, sound friendly but persuasive, and use the time.

Tone is the one people forget. CELPIP's own sample analysis marks down a correct, relevant Task 5 answer because it didn't sound persuasive enough for someone trying to convince their family. You are not presenting a report. You are winning an argument with someone you like.

Why Task 5 answers ramble

The same five habits come up again and again in mock tests. Each one eats seconds without earning anything.

  1. Reading the screen aloud. "Option A has three bedrooms, a balcony and costs $1,900." The rater can see that. They want to hear what the details mean for the person you're talking to.
  2. Too many reasons. Four reasons in 60 seconds means four half-finished thoughts. Two reasons, each with a detail, sound more organised and more fluent.
  3. Criticising instead of comparing. "Your idea is bad because it's far" is an opinion. "Mine is ten minutes away and yours is forty" is a comparison. Put both options on the same yardstick.
  4. Forgetting who you're talking to. Your manager cares about cost and deadlines. Your younger brother cares about fun and not being bored. Pick reasons for that person.
  5. No ending. Answers either trail off at 45 seconds ("so yeah, that's it") or get cut off mid-sentence. Both make the response feel unfinished.

A 60-second structure that holds up

Use five moves. The timings are rough. Nobody is counting seconds, but this keeps you from spending 40 seconds on the first reason.

  1. Open (about 5 seconds). Name the person, nod to their idea, and state your choice. "Priya, I get why you like the gym near your office, but I really think the community centre is better for us."
  2. Reason one (about 20 seconds). Pick one point, such as cost, distance, time or comfort. Say how both options compare on it, then what that means for the listener.
  3. Reason two (about 20 seconds). A different point, same pattern.
  4. Fair point (optional, about 5 seconds). Admit one thing their option does better, then turn it. "Yes, yours is cheaper, but you'd spend the savings on bus fare."
  5. Close (5 to 10 seconds). A clear ask or next step. "Let's sign up this weekend and try it for a month."

Inside each reason, use one pattern: mine versus yours, then what it means for you. "The community centre is a ten-minute walk, while your gym is a forty-minute drive in traffic. That's over an hour a week you'd get back."

At a relaxed pace, 60 seconds is roughly 120 to 150 words. Treat that as a sense of scale, not a target. Speaking faster to fit more in usually hurts Listenability more than it helps Content.

Using the two preparation minutes

Part 1 (60 seconds). Decide within about 15 seconds. Pick the option you can argue for most easily, not the one you'd choose in real life. Spend the rest of the minute noticing its two strongest features.

Part 2 (60 seconds). Read their option and find two direct comparisons where yours wins. Then fix your first sentence and your last sentence. If you know how you start and how you finish, the middle is much easier. Don't script full sentences in your head; you'll freeze trying to remember them.

A worked example with a model answer

This is an original practice task written in the CELPIP style.

Part 1. Your family wants to find a weekly activity for your grandmother so she stays active and meets people. Choose one:

  • Option A: A gentle yoga class at the community centre. Ten minutes' walk from her home. Tuesday and Thursday mornings. $40 a month.
  • Option B: A swimming group at a recreation centre. A 25-minute bus ride. Coffee meet-up after each session. $55 a month.

You choose Option A.

Part 2. Your brother Arjun suggests an online chair-exercise class she can do at home, any time, for $20 a month. Persuade him that your choice is better.

Model answer (about 140 words):

Arjun, I know the online class looks easy, and it's the cheapest, but I really think the yoga class at the community centre is better for Nani. First, the whole point is for her to meet people. Online, she'd be exercising alone in the living room, while at the centre she'd see the same group twice a week and actually make friends. Second, it's only a ten-minute walk, so she gets extra movement just getting there, and she won't need us for rides. Yes, it costs twenty dollars more a month, but I'm happy to split that with you. And honestly, you know she'll skip an online class the minute her favourite show comes on. Let's take her to a trial class this Tuesday and see what she thinks.

Why it works:

  • The first sentence names Arjun, admits his option's appeal and states the choice.
  • Both reasons compare the same feature of both options: meeting people, then getting there.
  • The cost concession is turned into a solution instead of being ignored.
  • None of it reads the details off the screen. "Ten minutes' walk" becomes "she won't need us for rides".
  • It ends on a specific next step, well inside the 60 seconds.

Comparison language worth having ready

Learn phrases, not paragraphs. A memorised opening that doesn't fit the situation sounds memorised, and raters hear a lot of them. (More on that in Can examiners tell if you're using a template?)

JobPhrases
State your choice"I really think ___ is the better option for us." / "I'd go with ___, and here's why."
Compare"___ is closer / cheaper / more flexible than ___." / "Compared with ___, ___." / "___, whereas ___."
Show the benefit"That means you'd ___." / "So you wouldn't have to ___."
Concede, then turn"I'll admit ___ is cheaper, but ___." / "That's a fair point, although ___."
Close"Why don't we try ___ first?" / "Let's go with ___ and see how it works."

Two phrases to drop: "on the left-hand side" and "on the right-hand side". They describe the screen, not the options, and CELPIP's own feedback flags them as unnecessary.

How to practise Task 5 at home

Ten minutes a day is enough if you do it with a timer and a recording.

  1. Take a Task 5 from the free official CELPIP practice tests, or build one from real life: two flats on a rental site, two phone plans, two weekend trips.
  2. Give yourself 60 seconds to choose. Then ask someone to pick a third option, or pick one yourself from the same site.
  3. Take 60 seconds to prepare, then record 60 seconds on your phone.
  4. Listen back once and check four things. Did you name the person in your first sentence? Did both reasons compare the same feature of both options? Did you finish with an ask before the minute ended? How many times did you restart a sentence?
  5. Record the same task again straight away, this time arguing for the other Part 1 option. CELPIP's own study material suggests this, and it stops you relying on one favourite argument.

If 60 seconds of preparation feels impossible at first, give yourself two minutes. Cut it down over a week or two until the real timing feels normal.

Questions students ask about Task 5

How long is CELPIP Speaking Task 5?

Three minutes in total: 60 seconds to choose between two options (no speaking), 60 seconds to prepare after the other person's option appears, and 60 seconds to speak.

Can I change my choice in Part 2?

No. Part 2 asks you to persuade the other person that the option you chose in Part 1 is better than theirs. Arguing for their option, or for the one you rejected, misses the task.

Should I mention the option I didn't pick in Part 1?

There's no need. In Part 2 the comparison is your choice against their new option. Bringing back the third one wastes time and muddies the comparison.

How many reasons should I give?

Two, each with a specific detail, is the sweet spot for 60 seconds. A third reason only helps if you are fluent enough to finish it cleanly.

What if I finish before the 60 seconds are up?

End with your request or next step rather than stopping abruptly. If you regularly finish at 40 seconds in practice, add one supporting detail to each reason rather than a new reason.

Can I sound strongly persuasive, or is that rude?

Persuasive is the point, but stay friendly. Admit one good thing about their idea, then explain why yours still wins. Mocking their choice works against you on tone.

Do I need a Canadian accent?

No. Raters listen for clear pronunciation, steady rhythm and natural intonation. An Indian accent that is easy to follow is perfectly fine.

Want someone to listen to your Task 5?

Recording yourself catches a lot, but not everything. In a free 30-minute assessment, I'll give you a Task 5 live, listen to your answer and tell you which of the four dimensions is holding your Speaking level back. If you'd like regular feedback, one-to-one CELPIP coaching includes full mock tests and written feedback after every class.

Working on Writing too? Try the free CELPIP Writing Checker. Need to know what your target level is worth in Express Entry points? Use the score converter.

Sources

CELPIP is a trademark of Prometric Canada. Prep with Suman is not affiliated with Prometric.

Suman Joshi
Suman Joshi

Suman spent four years as a senior trainer at an authorised CELPIP and IELTS test centre in Chandigarh and has taught English for over 20 years. She coaches CELPIP, IELTS and spoken English online, one to one.

Want this checked on your own writing?

Send me one task on WhatsApp and I will mark it for free, or book a full assessment.

Not on the list?
Looking for a different kind of English class?

CELPIP, IELTS and spoken English are what I coach. If you need something else, message me on WhatsApp and I will tell you honestly whether I can help.

Message on WhatsApp
Free · 30 minutes · no obligation

Start with a free assessment.

We'll look at your target, your starting point and your timeline, and you'll leave with a clear next step whether or not you sign up. Rather start with writing? Send me one Writing task on WhatsApp and I'll mark it for free.

Live in or near Chandigarh and want classes in person? Book the same free call and tell me. Ask about in-person classes

PrepwithSuman

One-to-one CELPIP, IELTS and spoken English coaching with Suman Joshi. Online anywhere; exam coaching also in person in Chandigarh.

Other English classes? WhatsApp us →
Coaching CELPIP IELTS Spoken English Pricing
Free tools Score Converter IELTS Writing Checker CELPIP Writing Checker Guides
Suman About Where I teach Results Book a free assessment

IELTS is jointly owned by the British Council, IDP IELTS and Cambridge University Press & Assessment. CELPIP and CAEL are registered trademarks of Prometric Canada Inc. Prep with Suman is an independent coaching service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any test owner.

© 2026 Prep with Suman

Free assessmentWhatsApp Suman